Recognizing Main Ideas for a Good
Summary
Many students have confused a request for a book review with a
basic summary. Please go to the Critical
Review page for a general description of a book review. In a
history, political science, or geography class, you will often
need to summarize information in your own words for oral or
written presentations. A good summary comes from a good reading
of the document first. As you read the text you want to
summarize, ask yourself the following questions:
What is the author's main point? How do
we know?
What evidence is offered to support it?
What other evidence would you like to see here in order to show
its points more persuasive in a debate with another author from
the chapter? Are you convinced that the evidence "proves" the
point?
In what ways may our own personal
experiences have prevented us from getting the point? What
prejudices would we as Americans have in this regard?
After your summary is organized and put onto note cards, work
with your home team to double check it for the following
characteristics of a good summary:
- no key ideas are omitted
- no new ideas are introduced
- no personal ideas of the summarizer are included
- the original author's point of view is maintained
- the words used are the summarizer's, not the original
writer's
For your presentation of a summary (whether oral or written),
follow this outline:
Introduction: Tell the audience exactly what you plan to
report -- the name of your excerpt, its author (and author's
background) and when it was written.
Body: Give the events/main points in the order they
happened in the text you are summarizing, using signal words such
as "first", "second", "next" and "finally". Check to see if you
have used words your audience knows; put yourself in the
listener's place and try to make sense of the order: is it
logical? confusing? should you write key terms up in a separate
list? As you show your author's main points, include other
viewpoints from your chapter in order to be persuasive.
Conclusion: Tell how the order of events/main points
ended. What is the final step or conclusion -- how does your
author answer the main question? Double-check to make sure the
events are clear and in order. Try out your summary on a member
of your study group before you rewrite your speech notecards or
written draft.
Posted May 17, 1996; Revised February 12, 2003
http://www.bluegrass.kctcs.edu/LCC/HIS